• Home
  • Articles
    • Art guides for beginners
    • Coloured Pencils
    • Graphite Pencils
    • Soft Pastels
    • Acrylic Paints
    • Water based Products
    • Oil-based products
    • Papers & Canvases
    • Art Accessories
  • Tutorials
  • Workshops
  • News
  • Kofi-blog
  • About
  • Mail Us
  • Site Map
STEP BY STEP ART
  • Home
  • Articles
    • Art guides for beginners
    • Coloured Pencils
    • Graphite Pencils
    • Soft Pastels
    • Acrylic Paints
    • Water based Products
    • Oil-based products
    • Papers & Canvases
    • Art Accessories
  • Tutorials
  • Workshops
  • News
  • Kofi-blog
  • About
  • Mail Us
  • Site Map

A list of coloured pencil brands | Compare and contrast


Arteza colored pencils - tin of 120 colours
An article will follow about these pencils

Arteza coloured pencils
Wax based

Colours: 120
Lead strength: Medium 
​Lead thickness: 4.5mm
Lightfast rating: Unsure
Availability: Tins of 48, 72 and 120 plus circular tub of 48
Vegan friendly: Not tested on animals
Environmentally friendly: Unsure
PROS:
​Low-cost brand
Good range of colours

CONS:
Highly unlikely to be 100% lightfast although earthy colours such as greens and browns fade less than the other colours.

Karen's personal opinion:
A nice set of pencils, ideal for kids and students or those starting out with coloured pencils as a medium. An article will follow on these pencils where I will spend more time trialling these pencils and will update this section in time.
Caran d'Ache Luminance pencils
Click to read our article
View colour chart

Caran d'Ache Luminance pencils
Wax based

Colours: 100 and a colourless blender
Lead thickness: 3.8mm
Lead strength: Medium 
Lightfast rating: ATSM - 6901
Availability: Open stock, Tin sets of 16, 38 & 76, Box Sets of 20, 40 & 76,
​20 Portrait box set
Wooden box of 80 (inc. 4 repeat colours)
24 New colours released July 2020
Vegan friendly: Yes
Environmentally friendly: Yes, FSC Cedar wood certified
PROS:
Professional quality product with strong pigments
​High Lightfast ratings (100+ years)

Allows for extensive layering
Excellent blendability
CONS:
Expensive
​Might be too soft for some artists

Karen's personal opinion:
My personal choice of coloured pencils. Having tried a few popular brands in the last few years, the Luminance pencils are the only brand that allows me to apply layer after layer, light over dark without becoming saturated too quickly. They are soft enough to create smooth transitions for tonal backgrounds and ideal for portraits when creating skin tones as well as being hard enough to create fine lines in hair & fur. Being primarily a pet portrait artist, the Luminance pencil range has a wide choice of neutral colours perfect for most portraits whilst offering a good range of greens & blues for landscape in backgrounds seemingly the 100 colours in the range may have been chosen to minimise unnecessary colours.
Tin of 76 Caran Dache Museum Aquarelle pencils
Click the image to read the Museum Aquarelle pencils article
View colour chart (Link to follow)

Caran d'Ache Museum Aquarelle pencils
Wax based

Colours: 76      (53 of the colours match the Luminance range)
Lead strength: Medium 
Lead thickness: 3.8mm
Lightfast rating: Blue wool scale
Availability: Open stock, Box Sets of 12, 20, 40 & 76,
Wooden box of 80 (inc. 3 Technalo and 1 Grafwood graphite pencils)
Vegan friendly: Yes
Environmentally friendly: Yes, FSC Cedar wood certified
PROS:
Ultra high pigment concentration
​Highly lightfast for a water based pencil range
​23 colours not found in the Luminance range
Hexagonal barrel stops the pencil rolling off surfaces
CONS:
Only 76 colours
Some colours are not very lightfast 

Karen's personal opinion:
Information to follow...
Derwent Chromaflow coloured pencils
A Chromaflow article will follow
View colour chart

Derwent Chromaflow pencils
Wax based

Colours: 72 
Lead Strength: Medium
Lead thickness: 3.5mm
Lightfast Rating: Blue Wool
​Availability: Open stock, Tins of 12, 24, 36, 48 and 72
Vegan friendly: Yes
Environmentally friendly: Yes, sustainably sourced
PROS:
A good choice of colours in the palette
Many colours are lightfast
CONS:
Some colours have poor lightfast ratings
Some breakages have been observed
Expensive for the student market that these pencils are aimed at

Karen's personal opinion:
I have mixed feelings about these pencils. They feel more of a student quality and are quite expensive for this reason. They are currently priced at £1.80 per pencil, but I feel they should be more £1.20-£1.40 pp. They have thin barrels like the Lyra and Prismacolor brands, unlike most other Derwent pencils. The wood seems to be of lower quality than their other ranges and the application is dry and not as strong or vibrant. Some of the colours, and pigments, match those in the Derwent Lightfast range, but the Chromaflow offer a more diverse tonal palette, with lighter colours that are not found in the Lightfast range (this is due to poor lightfast qualities in some paler pigments). The Chromaflow pencils could be used where colours are limited in the Lightfast, widening the colour palette, however, some of the colours have poor lightfast ratings.
Derwent Coloursoft coloured pencils
Click the image above to view the Coloursoft article
View colour chart

Derwent Coloursoft pencils
Wax based

Colours: 72 
Lead Strength: Soft
​Lead thickness: 4mm
Lightfast Rating: Blue Wool
​Availability: Open stock, Pack of 6 starter colours, pk of 6 skin tones, Tin sets of 12, 24, 36 & 72, Wooden box sets of 48 & 72
Vegan friendly: Yes
Environmentally friendly: Yes, sustainably sourced
PROS:
A well known company brand
Affordable
Great blendibility due to their softness, ideal for tonal applications
CONS:
Some colours have poor lightfast ratings
Care is needed when sharpening due to the softness of the lead

Karen's personal opinion:
When my favoured coloured pencil range Karisma was discontinued I tried the Derwent's Coloursoft range having heard others say they were very similar and since then I have used them as my secondary pencil range. Having soft leads, they blend particularly well especially for base tone applications and can achieve smooth transitions. The main problem with this range sadly is the poor lightfast rating on some of the colours such as the pinks, purples and the blues, which is the reason I tend to use them as undertones and cut down the wastage on my Caran Dache Luminance pencils. 

Related articles for coloured pencil artists

Picture
Comparing pencil brands
Coloured pencils in glass jars and a colour chart
Coloured pencils | A guide for beginners
Blending pencils, zest-it, blender pens and blending powder alyona nickelson
How to blend coloured pencils
Hot pressed watercolour papers including St Cuthbert Mills, Fabriano, Bockingford, Moulin du roy
Hot Pressed watercolour paper brands
Tin of 24 Derwent Drawing coloured pencils
Click the image to read the Drawing pencil article
View colour chart

Derwent Drawing pencils
Wax based

Colours: 24
Lead Strength: Medium
Lead thickness: 5mm
Lightfast Rating: Blue Wool
​Availability: Open stock  -  Blister pack of 6  -  Tin sets of 6, 12 and 24  -  Tub of 72 (3 of each colour)
Vegan friendly: Yes
Environmentally friendly: Yes, sustainably sourced
PROS:
Good price
High lightfast ratings
Earthy colours for various subjects such as landscape art
4mm thick lead
Chalky application (could be PRO or CON)
CONS:
Only 24 colours
Minimal choice of tonal range
Soft and chunky - Unsuitable for fine detail

Karen's personal opinion:
These pencils are a great set to have in your collection. They are all highly lightfast and the pigments are very rich. They are ideal for blocking in or creating tonal bases or backgrounds as they are chunky and layer smoothly. The selection of tones in this collection, are earthy colours, ideal for landscapes but can be used in conjunction with other pencil ranges. If you own no other colour from this collection, I would highly recommend purchasing the Ivory Black & the Chinese White pencils as they have such strong pigments and are very opaque. There are 13 colours in this collection that match the Derwent Lightfast ones, but the applications are different - the lightfast are buttery and can achieve finer detail where as the drawing ones are a little drier and do not allow for very fine detail due to the 4mm lead thickness.
Derwent Lightfast coloured pencils
Click the image to read our article
View colour chart

Derwent Lightfast pencils
Oil based

Colours: 100 colours 
Lead Strength: Hard
​Lead thickness: 4mm
Lightfast Rating: ASTM 6901
​Availability: Open stock, Tin sets of 12, 24, 36, & 72 Wooden box of 48 and 100
Vegan friendly: Yes
Environmentally friendly: Yes, sustainably sourced
PROS:
A well known company brand with their very first 100% lightfast pencil range
Strong pigments
​No wax bloom
An oil based pencil that blends like a wax based pencil offering a smooth application
CONS:
Expensive
Do not intermix well (light over dark)
​Fixative not effective

Karen's personal opinion:
I'm not a user of oil based pencils as I have found that I am unable to layer extensively with them like I can with wax-based pencils but this range feels different to other oil-based pencils. The blendibility is one of the best I have come across and you only need to apply slight pressure before the pigment adhered to the paper. The pencils are quite soft which is strange for an oil based pencil as they tend to have a harder core, allowing you to create very fine detail that you may struggle with wax based pencils as they tend to be softer. Derwent breaking all the rules with this one.
Derwent Metallic pencils
An article about these pencils will follow
View colour chart

Derwent Metallic pencils
Oil based

Colours: 20 colours 
Lead Strength: Medium
Lead thickness: 3.5mm
Lightfast Rating: ASTM 6901
​Availability: Open stock, Sets of 6, 12 and 20
Vegan friendly: Yes
Environmentally friendly: Yes, sustainably sourced
PROS:
Opaque pigments
Vibrant colours
Most colours are highly lightfast
CONS:
Not a large range of tones
Not all colours are lightfast

Karen's personal opinion:
I've never used metallic pencils in my professional work. Metallic pencils usually have poor lightfast ratings, and I avoid them purely for this very reason. Derwent has updated their metallic pencil range and brought out this lovely looking set of 20. As most art companies put lightfastness at the top of their list of importance, and noting that almost all their pencils have good ratings, I thought I would give them a go. They are highly pigmented and creamy. Ideal for adding flecks of light to many subjects, especially effective on darker paper tones. 
Tin of the 72 set of Derwent Procolour pencils
Click the image above to read the Procolour article
View colour chart

Derwent Procolour pencils
Wax based

Colours: 72
Lead Strength: Hard
Lead thickness: 4mm
Lightfast Rating: Blue Wool
​Availability: Open stock, Tin sets of 12, 24, 36 & 72, Wooden Box Sets of 24, 36 & 72
Vegan friendly: Yes
Environmentally friendly: Yes, sustainably sourced
PROS:
A well known company brand
Strong pigments
Wax based feels like oil based and keep a sharp point for longer
Does not leave dust on the paper due to the hardness of the leads
CONS:
Poor lightfast ratings in many of the colours
Can cause wax bloom after too many applications
Do not intermix (light over dark)

Karen's personal opinion:
I like that these pencils have very hard leads even though they are waxed based, which is quite unusual, and there is no dust left behind which you may find in softer leads however they do not layer and blend as well as other wax based pencils and the lightfastness of many of the colours are poor. The pigments are vibrant though and the lightfast qualities can be improved upon in future if Derwent decides to continue the range, plus any artwork can easily be protected with specialised glass when framing so this might not be a huge issue to the Procolour lovers.
Our articles are never finished.
​As more products appear on the market, we continue to extend our articles to incorporate these products.

​If you found this article helpful, please share using the tabs on this page (not available on a mobile)
​Why not bookmark and come back at a later date to see what we have added.
Thank you for viewing!
Wooden box set of the Faber Castell Polychromos Coloured pencils
Click the image to read the article

Faber Castell Polychromos Pencils
Oil based

Colours: 120
Lead Strength: Hard
Lead thickness: 3.8mm
Lightfast Rating: Blue Wool
​Availability: Open stock, Tin sets of 12, 24, 36, 48, 60 & 120, Wooden box Set of 48, 72 and 120
Vegan friendly: Yes
Environmentally friendly: Yes, FSC sustainably sourced
PROS:
Extremely popular with pencil artists
Professional quality product with strong pigments
High lightfast ratings (100+ years)
Not expensive for a professional, lightfast range
Waterproof leads making them resistant to smudging
​Blendable with solvents
SV bonding prevents unnecessary breakage (the lead is glued to the wood inside)

CONS:
Can not layer extensively

Karen's personal opinion:
I have seen so many artists out there that create some amazing and detailed work with these pencils that I feel a little uncomfortable saying that these pencils are sadly not my cup of tea. They have so many wonderful qualities coming from a well established company like Faber Castell, you certainly can't go wrong having this range in your collection if you prefer oil based coloured pencils. I like to layer extensively with my coloured pencils and find oil based pencils do not allow me to do this and is the only reason I do not personally use them. If the Caran Dache Luminance are the Rolls Royce of wax pencils, then Polychromos are the Rolls Royce of the oil based pencils - it's simply about technique and preference really.
Box of 108 Berol Karisma pencils set
Click the image to view the Karismacolor article

(Berol) Karismacolor pencils
Wax based - Discontinued

Colours:  129 
Lead Strength: Soft
​Lead thickness: 4mm
Lightfast Rating: Blue Wool
Availability: Discontinued - stock still regularly shows up on eBay
Vegan friendly: Probably not, going by the fact the Premier pencils are not vegan friendly
Environmentally friendly: Although not confirmed, it is likely they are as the Premier pencils are.
PROS:
Great blendibility, creamy application
Wide range of colours, especially greys
Grey and Brown tones were the most lightfast
CONS:
Now discontinued
Prone to breakage due to the softness of the leads (although quality was much better than today's Prismacolor)
Many colours had poor lightfast qualities

 Karen's personal opinion:
I was a big fan of the Berol Karisma color pencils when they were readily available. They were the European version of the Prismacolor Premier pencil range but sadly discontinued back in 2005 apparently due to falling sales in the European market. They were a mix between the Caran Dache Luminance and Derwent Coloursoft pencils in their softness and I have bought single pencils when old stock has appeared online particularly on auction sites, where sets still turn up from time to time, be prepared to pay high prices though, I've seen large box sets sell for around £400+ in top condition! A real loss to Karisma lovers when they were discontinued.
Polycolor Lyra coloured pencils
An article will follow on these pencils

Lyra Rembrandt Polycolor Pencils
Oil based

Colours: 72 + a Splender Blender
Lead Strength: Medium
​Lead thickness: 4mm
Lightfast Rating: Star rating
​Availability: Open stock, Tins of 12, 24, 36 & 72 - Tin of 12 Assorted greys (profi-plus)
Wooden Box Set of 100 plus accessories
Vegan friendly: ??
Environmentally friendly: Yes, sustainably sourced
PROS:
Strong pigments
Affordable
Great blendibility due to their softness, ideal for tonal applications
CONS:
Many colours have poor lightfast ratings
​Not as easy to access open stock and sets in some countries
Care is needed when sharpening due to the softness of the lead

Karen's personal opinion:
These pencils may confuse some as oil based pencils tend to be hard but these are relatively soft and some colours have a tendency to be brittle or may leave dust behind even on smooth paper.  I only own a few of these pencils, mainly the grey profi-plus set and so have not yet delved into the possibilities of them at any length to offer a true opinion, but I am not a fan of the thin pencil barrel as it makes my hand ache during use, however these pencils look good quality and you may find sets are relatively cheap online making them suitable as a starter set.

Related articles for coloured pencil artists

Pencil storage chest. Holds 250 pencils.
Need storage? Holds 250 pencils.
Peacock feather coloured pencil drawing and derwent lightfast pencils
Try one of our coloured pencil mini tutorials
Sumatran Tiger on Colourfix using Caran d'Ache Luminance pencils
Working with textured paper | For coloured pencil artists
Black papers; Derwent, Art Spectrum Colourfix smooth, Sakura notebook
12 black papers for artists
Prismacolor Premier coloured pencil
Read our Prismacolor Premier article
View colour chart

Prismacolor Premier Pencils
Wax based

Colours: 150 & a Blender
Lead Strength: Soft
​Lead thickness: 4mm
Lightfast Rating: ATSM-6901
​Availability:  Open stock, Tins of 12, 24, 36, 48, 72, 132, 150
Vegan friendly: No
Environmentally friendly: Yes, sustainably sourced
PROS:
Vibrant pigments
Affordable
Creamy application and good blendibility
Large selection of colours
CONS:
Some artists complain of poor quality pencils such as damaged leads or that the lead falls out of the wooden barrel. Complaints of this nature span over a 12 year period.
Some colours have poor lightfast ratings

Karen's personal opinion:
These pencils are extremely popular for a reason. The vibrancy, the creaminess, the low price and the wide selection of colours all make this range very attractive to many BUT I am aware of the number of complaints I have have read which span over a 12 year period. The company may prefer to balance cost-effectiveness with the acceptance that a small amount of products will be flawed in someway.
Prismacolor Verithin coloured pencils
An article will follow about these pencils
View colour chart

Prismacolor Verithin Pencils
Wax based

Colours: 36
Lead Strength: Hard
Lead thickness: 3.5mm
Lightfast Rating: ATSM-6901
​Availability:  Open stock, Boxes of 6, 12, 24 & 36
Vegan friendly: No
Environmentally friendly: Yes, sustainably sourced
PROS:
Ideal for fine detailing - used alongside the Premier range
Affordable
CONS:
Some artists complain of poor quality pencils such as damaged leads or that the lead falls out of the wooden barrel. Complaints of this nature span over a 12 year period.
Some colours have poor lightfast ratings
​

Karen's personal opinion:
I have a few of these pencils. I bought a pack of 12 a few years ago and was given a handful of the Verithin pencils which were made in the USA rather than the current manufacturers, and the difference in application and pigment is notable. I have found that the newer pencils have a tendency to break easily when attempting to sharpen them, so care must be taken.
Tin of 36 Royal Talens Van Gogh Coloured pencils set
Click the image above to view the Van Gogh pencils article

Royal Talens Van Gogh Pencils
Wax based

Colours: 60
Lead Strength: Soft
Lead thickness: 3.5mm
​Lightfast Rating: ASTM 6901
​Availability: Open stock, Tin sets of 12, 24, 36 & 60
Vegan friendly: ??
Environmentally friendly: Yes, sustainably sourced
PROS:
Vibrant and strong colour application
Smooth, creamy and soft pencils
​Superb Lightfastness
CONS:
Hard to find open stock
Not available in the USA
Some colours such as white, appear more translucent
​

Karen's personal opinion:
These coloured pencils are much like the Prismacolor Premier coloured pencils but slightly dryer. They boast of pure pigment and so colours are vibrant which lay down wonderfully on paper with a slight tooth, only needing to apply a gentle pressure to achieve the vibrancy. The best quality about these pencil is the ASTM-6901 lightfast rating  that only a few pencil brands can boast, yet the prices are much cheaper if you can get them that is as there are very few stockists with open stock available although you can find a link above to a UK seller that ships these pencils worldwide. 
Box of 48 WH Smith Coloured pencils set
Click the image above to read the article on these pencils

WH Smith's Pencils
Wax based

Colours: 48
Lead Strength: Medium
Lead thickness: 3.5mm
Lightfast Rating: None
​Availability:  Boxes of 12, 24, 36 + 48
Vegan friendly: No
Environmentally friendly: No
PROS:
Good pigments
Extremely affordable
Extensive layering possible
CONS:
Only available from WH Smith outlets (although can be found in some airports worldwide)
​Not lightfast
Pigment of the white pencil is poor
Few natural/earth colours

Karen's personal opinion:
I don't tend to touch cheap coloured pencils as there always tends to be more binder than pigment creating low quality pencils and poor application, so this brand surprised me when one of my students turned up to an art workshop one day with a set and I saw what they could achieve - I now use them in all my workshops as they give great coverage, layer extensively and can achieve professional looking results. Although they only have two greys and five browns, aren't lightfast and are only available in the UK, for those who can access them they are perfect for the newbie to coloured pencils. A box of 48 costs just £10.99 and WH Smith often have deals  so you can buy them as part of an offer.

Article first written: February 2019
Pencil brands are added when available

QUICK LINKS

​Articles
Art Tutorials

Art Workshops  

Workshop Gift Vouchers

Art Blog

About ko-fi
​Our social media page
​

About the Tutor  
Contact  

Site Map
Vertical Divider
Picture
Instagram logo
You Tube logo
Green Animal friendly logo

HOW TO SUPPORT US

Colourful coffee cup digital image

Thank you for visiting our website, which offers valuable global resources for artists. We strive to provide a pleasant browsing experience by keeping our site advertisements-free. We do not earn money from this website, but you can show appreciation by buying us a coffee on ko-fi.com. You will find the donation buttons below and can follow us on ko-fi to stay informed of the latest news. We appreciate your visit!​
​
​
What is Ko-fi?
No part of this website should be copied or re-used anywhere without written permission from Karen M Berisford - 2011 - 2023
All images on this website are copyright of Karen M Berisford unless otherwise stated - Website design by Karen M Berisford. All rights Reserved.
  • Home
  • Articles
    • Art guides for beginners
    • Coloured Pencils
    • Graphite Pencils
    • Soft Pastels
    • Acrylic Paints
    • Water based Products
    • Oil-based products
    • Papers & Canvases
    • Art Accessories
  • Tutorials
  • Workshops
  • News
  • Kofi-blog
  • About
  • Mail Us
  • Site Map